Three Wheels of Magic ($2,995) vs. Catrike Villager eCAT ($5,850) - Side by Side Comparison

1. Overview and Purpose

• Catrike Villager eCat: Known for its high seat and comfortable riding position, the eCat is designed for riders who value ease of access, stability, and versatility in urban and recreational settings. It comes with Catrike's well-regarded build quality, coupled with a Bosch eAssist system.

• Falco Three Wheels of Magic (TWM): Designed for riders seeking a highly customizable electric trike with a focus on rehabilitation, adaptability, and wireless connectivity. The TWM is equipped with Falco's proprietary motor and wireless console, making it ideal for users who prioritize technological integration and modularity.

2. Frame and Build Quality

• Material: Aluminum frame, known for its lightweight and durability.
• Design: Higher seat height (12.5 inches) for easier mounting and dismounting, making it suitable for people with limited mobility.
• Weight: Approximately 37 lbs without electric assist.

• Material: Chromoly or aluminum options, depending on user preference and customization.
• Design: The TWM features an 8" ground clearance for versatility in various terrains, and it’s built to be adaptable for people in rehabilitation or requiring modifications for comfort and mobility.
• Weight: Estimated at around 45 lbs without electric assist.

3. Electric Assist System

• Motor: Bosch Active Line Plus, a 250W motor, known for smooth power delivery and reliability.
• Battery: Bosch PowerPack 400 or 500, offering good range and efficient energy use.
• Control System: Bosch Purion display for ease of use, featuring a minimalist interface and controls.

• Motor: Falco Hx Liquid Cooled motor, which is more powerful at 750W and features a 5-phase direct-drive system for higher torque and efficiency.
• Battery: 36 or 48V lithium battery with customizable capacity (ranging from 400 Wh to 672 Wh), offering potentially greater range than the eCat’s system.
• Control System: Wireless 8" Android-based console for enhanced functionality, including real-time metrics, customizable displays, and Bluetooth Smart integration.

4. Performance and Range

• Range: Approximately 50-70 miles per charge, depending on the terrain, rider weight, and assistance level.
• Top Speed: Max assisted speed of 20 mph in line with e-bike laws.
• Ride Feel: Smooth, with predictable power delivery and good control for urban and recreational use.

• Range: 60-100+ miles, depending on battery capacity and riding conditions.
• Top Speed: Max assisted speed of 28 mph (can be adjusted according to local laws).
• Ride Feel: The Falco motor delivers high torque, especially helpful for riders on hilly or uneven terrain, with the potential for faster speeds and better acceleration.

5. Comfort and Ergonomics

• Seat: Ergonomic seat with mesh backing, designed for a comfortable upright position.
• Adjustability: Adjustable seat recline and boom length to accommodate different rider heights.
• Suspension: No suspension, but the high ground clearance and tire size provide some cushioning.

• Seat: Adaptive seating options for rehabilitation purposes, including mesh or cushioned seats.
• Adjustability: Customizable to the rider’s needs, including seat recline, boom length, and adaptive components for rehabilitation users.
• Suspension: Not included as standard, but it offers a robust build that allows for comfortable riding even over rougher terrains.

6. Technology and Features

• Display: Bosch Purion, providing basic riding metrics such as speed, battery life, and assistance level.
• Lights: Optional LED light kits for visibility.
• Other: Comes with Catrike's standard accessories like a rear cargo rack.

• Display: 8" wireless Android console, fully customizable with real-time data. This allows for greater interaction and adaptability for the user.
• Lights: Optional LED Lights.
• Other: Offers modular add-ons, including wireless connectivity and customizable torque settings.

7. Target Audience

• Catrike Villager eCat: Targeted toward recreational riders, seniors, and those who want a reliable and simple trike for urban or light trail use.
• Falco TWM: Designed for a broader audience, including those with rehabilitation needs, tech enthusiasts, or riders who need a more powerful and customizable system.

8. Price

• Catrike Villager eCat: $5,850 for the electric assist model.
• Falco TWM: $2,995 for the base trike, with additional costs for the motor and other optional accessories (total cost may exceed $3,500 depending on customization).

9. Pros and Cons

• Pros: Reliable Bosch system, well-built frame, easy to mount, good for recreational use.
• Cons: Less powerful motor, limited to 20 mph, fewer customization options.

• Pros: More powerful motor, customizable for rehabilitation, advanced wireless technology, potentially greater range and speed.
• Cons: Heavier, may require more technical setup for customization.

Conclusion

For urban and recreational riders who prioritize simplicity and reliability, the Catrike Villager eCat is an excellent choice. However, for those who want greater customization, rehabilitation benefits, and cutting-edge technology, the Falco Three Wheels of Magic stands out with its more powerful motor and innovative wireless system.